Post
by Matt Bach » Mon Jun 20, 2011 8:37 pm
Just to confuse everyone further, I think I want to retract my above statements. I can't edit the post so I want to explain why I'm changing my mind. I do apologise for the threadjacking.
I did a test today on a sheet of light white paper. I used diggers shellite, venti lighter fluid and diggers white spirit, putting each liquid on the paper, expecting any residue to remain on/in the paper after evaporation. I used a couple of pipettes and squirted some down the page, marking what was what. I wasn't particularly concerned with exact mls but I used enough to wet the paper in roughly equal amounts.
After one minute the shellite had disappeared; the lighter fluid soon after; the white spirit took a while but was gone within 20 mins. This was expected, but eventually, after they were all dry, there was no trace of contamination. Even when held up to a floodlight/daylight I could not see any discolouration or even tell where the liquid was to start with.
I repeated the test on a bit of scratchplate plastic with the same results. I took pictures but they are extremely uninteresting. I might try it tomorrow with some actual wood (in which case I'd expect longer drying but still no trace after drying).
I maintain they all smell different but I'm not going to sniff any more lest I loose more brain cells. I guess that's what they mean by "aromatic hydrocarbons"...
Feel free to replicate the test but I guess the moral is that if you let it dry it shouldn't ever be a problem.
I think perhaps when I was using the products in the past, something else was causing the oilyness; maybe my own misunderstanding of the products drying time, maybe a reaction with an existing polish or the rag itself, or any number of things including my early onset dementia.